Going For A Spin
Are additional companies worth the investment for
distributors?
In addition to the strategies mentioned in the previous
story, material handling distributors also sometimes
have the opportunity to create a spin-off company to
bring in additional revenue. Whether that is its stated
purpose or not, having another source of income is important.
Struggles in the core business can be offset by gains
in the spin-off (and vice versa, of course). Some spin-offs
are used to focus a company on a new area of expertise.
Some companies create spin-offs to take advantage of
manufacturing capabilities in addition to their already
strong distribution operations. Below are four examples
of spin-offs created by MHEDA Members.
|
|
Utilizing Engineering Resources at
Zinter Handling
For Saratoga Springs, New York-based Zinter Handling, it
was a matter of making better use of its human resources. We
had more resources in engineering than we were utilizing,
President Scott Zinter says. Zinter and his father, Zinter
Handling CEO Lawrence Zinter, decided to expand the manufacturing
side of the business into a separate company, Saratoga Crane & Monorail.
The original company is Zinter Handling, and it has always
dealt primarily with end-users within a few hundred miles of our
home base, Scott Zinter says. The purpose of Saratoga
Crane & Monorail was to do the engineering and manufacturing, but
not the sales and installation. We do that through our dealer network.
 |
| Zinter Handling set up Saratoga Crane
& Monorail to manufacture products such as this 40-ton
capacity Papermill Duty Crane. |
|
Saratoga Crane & Monorail manufactures overhead cranes and other
material hand-ling equipment from the Zinter Handling facility using
employees that it leases for a fee from Zinter Handling. In total,
30 employees feed both companies. We set it up that way for
practicality, to take advantage of the infrastructure already in
place at Zinter Handling. If we don't take advantage of the duplication
within the two organizations, our expenses will rise, Zinter
says. About 20 percent of the employees' time is centered on Saratoga
Crane & Monorail and about 80 percent on Zinter Handling. Lawrence
Zinter serves as Saratoga Crane & Monorail president.
Cost control is of special importance at Saratoga Crane & Monorail,
which does not deal directly with end-users. Its products are very
cost-sensitive because the distributors need to be able to add their
costs on top and still compete. We strive to keep Saratoga
Crane & Monorail's overhead extremely low, making it better able
to compete and give our distributors a good solid price that they
can take to the marketplace, Scott Zinter says.
| It is
a lot of work having a second company, so make sure there
is a true purpose for the spin-off that can not be handled
by your original company. |
| Scott
Zinter |
|
It didn't take long for the differences to emerge between the two
different styles of companies. With Zinter Handling, a lot
of the emphasis goes on the service side of the business, whereas
Saratoga Crane & Monorail utilizes the engineering infrastructure
that we have in place without all the difficulties that are associated
with 24/7 service, Zinter explains. The difference was particularly
driven home during the development of marketing tools such as sales
brochures, letterheads, envelopes and other promotional items. We
more or less created everything from scratch, and it was different
than what we were used to because it was directed for distributors
rather than end-users.
The Atlas Companies Set Up Separately
Five corporations comprise The Atlas Companies (Schiller
Park, IL): Atlas Toyota Material Handling, a distributor of forklifts
and attachments; Atlas Mid-America Energy, a propane distribution
firm; Atlas Bobcat, a distributor of construction equipment; Atlas
Material Handling, a supplier of racking and wire products; and
Atlas First Access, a distributor of sweepers and cleaning products.
 |
| Atlas First Access is one of five corporations
under the umbrella of The Atlas Companies. |
|
Each corporation has its own name under the banner of The Atlas
Companies and is run by CEO Howard Bernstein, who says, We
wanted to be diverse. We chose to make them separate corporations
so that the management teams could have independence and eventually
have the capability to split off if we so chose. That hasn't happened,
but that was the reason. Each corporation has been around
virtually from the outset of the company in the 1950s.
The five companies each have their own separate locations, including
branch locations, but the company's main facility in Schiller Park
serves as headquarters for all. You might say it's like a
holding company, Bernstein says. We have one accounting
department and one advertising department for all the corporations,
so we get the advantage of consolidated management and sharing of
facilities.
The diversity is important for generating new clientele. Our
construction equipment has a different base of customers than our
material handling equipment, so our mailing list and advertising
are directed toward different people. Our propane company has another
base, Bernstein says. Yet our advertising head is one
and the same for all the corporations. Each corporation has its
own name under the banner of The Atlas Companies.
Bernstein could have set everything up as one corporation and admits
it may even have been easier to do so. But this way offers more
flexibility. We wouldn't have five separate sets of books.
We have to file separate income tax returns, so there is some duplication
of effort in that regard, he says. But long range, we
prefer it, particularly as the company will inevitably change hands.
We have the flexibility that one corporation could remain intact
just the way it is, be sold intact or be spun off very easily.
Liftech Develops Software Company
ScottTech, an integration and software development company for
warehouse projects, was developed eight years ago by Joe Verzino,
president of Liftech Equipment Companies (East Syracuse,
NY). We were starting to get involved with a higher level
of warehouse projects, Verzino says. The average lift
truck salesperson didn't have time to deal with those drawn-out,
more complicated projects.
 |
| ScottTech offices are housed in Liftech
Equipment Company's corporate headquarters in East Syracuse,
New York. |
|
Consequently, Verzino partnered with material handling consultant
Herb Minor to handle warehouse projects. The volume of projects
kept growing, and the partners eventually determined that enough
business was available to create a second company. Any time
we at Liftech would get a request for a sophisticated warehouse
project, we gave it to ScottTech and they'd run with the ball,
Verzino says.
Soon after establishing ScottTech, it became evident that there
was a need to develop some software to track information in spinning
carousels and product pickers within the warehouse projects. An
employee who had written some code for the company was brought on
as a third partner to help grow that end of the business. We
were very fortunate, Verzino says. We had a need and
started to scratch the niche market that we looked to penetrate.
We started on a small scale and allowed the company to grow. I think
that was healthy.
| Be reasonable
in your projections. You don't want to put the core business,
the reason for starting this business, at risk. |
| Joe
Verzino |
|
Throughout its eight-year existence, Scott-Tech has shared space
at Liftech corporate headquarters. Within the last few months, ScottTech
moved into new office space in the Liftech building. As an owner
of the company, Liftech performs operational functions for human
resources, accounting and general administration. ScottTech programmers
and managers have offices, but there is less need for people to
physically work in the building. Among the company's 15 employees
are people residing in New Jersey, Ohio and other parts of New York.
Positive returns on the spin-off company took a bit longer than
expected, but Verzino rates the start-up about an eight out of ten.
Challenges did arise because it is a standalone business.
For example, a competitor to Liftech had a need that ScottTech could
help with, but he was reluctant because he thought he was feeding
business to Liftech, Verzino explains. But ScottTech
works directly with end-users, and that has seemed to work out very
well.
Barloworld Spins Off Acquisitions
Barloworld Handling (Charlotte, NC) is experienced in running
spin-off companies. In 1998, Barloworld acquired a Ditch Witch business
in the Southeast; it purchased a Freightliner truck dealership a
year later. Barloworld sold off both companies earlier this spring.
We initially decided that we wanted to diversify away from
our main product line while sticking to our core business, which
is providing equipment and aftermarket service, President
Stan Sewell says. We were looking for industrial brands
that did not compete with Hyster that allowed us to leverage our
ability to sell equipment, manage technicians, and provide maintenance
and service contracts.
 |
| Until recently, Barloworld heaquarters
in Charlotte provided centralized back office support
for two additional companies. |
|
The acquisitions were part of Barloworld's growth strategy. We
wanted to grow, but we couldn't do it with Hyster because we already
represent such a large part of their territory, Sewell says.
Barloworld formed a separate company for each, but provided centralized
back office functions out of the headquarters in Charlotte. We
still provided information technology, human resources, risk management,
accounting and payroll, Sewell explains. That's where
you get your synergy from multiple companies. The two companies
shared about 18 back office employees, mostly in information technology
and human resources. The Ditch Witch business employed 35 people
at one branch, while Freightliner had nine branches with about 500
employees.
Barloworld recently decided to sell the two companies, though it
wasn't due to poor results. Sewell says, Ditch Witch was generating
good cash flow, but we couldn't grow it beyond the state of Georgia.
What was our return on management effort for a business that is
only going to have organic growth? As for Freightliner, the
truck business proved too volatile for Barloworld shareholders.
Handle with Care
Obviously, no one formula works for everyone. The above companies
each have taken different approaches to their forays in establishing
additional companies. Spin-off companies can be a major boon for
distributors, but they must be handled properly. As Scott Zinter
warns, A lot of people set up a second company more as a way
to distribute or shield assets. But it is a lot of work having a
second company, so make sure there is a true purpose for it that
could not be handled by your original company.
Liftech's Joe Verzino concurs and adds, Too many people try
to make a profit in the first 12 months, but that is unrealistic
in many cases. Be reasonable in your projections. If you can't withstand
what you think is a conservative projection, then you probably shouldn't
be doing it. You don't want to put the core business, the reason
for starting this business, at risk.
The same advice comes from Stan Sewell at Barloworld. Look
long term at your strategic plan for those businesses and know exactly
what you want those businesses to achieve five and ten years down
the road, and make sure you have a game plan for getting there,
he says. More important, if you don't get there, what is your
exit strategy? You can't be bashful about unloading spin-off companies
if they don't end up meeting your strategic plan.
|